NewsGift Card Industry

35% of Adults Have Given or Received a Gift Card With No Money on It: What AARP's 2026 Holiday Scams Report Means for Company Gift Orders

AARP published its 2026 Holiday Shopping and Scams Report on November 11. Seven in ten holiday shoppers plan to give gift cards this year, and more than a third say they have already given or received one that turned out to be empty. For a company about to hand a card to every employee in December, that is a question about how the cards are bought, not only about consumer fraud.

By Maciej Kamieniak5 min read

The figures in the report

AARP runs this survey every year ahead of the holiday season. The 2026 edition covers the whole range of seasonal fraud — fake delivery texts, phony toll payments, fraudulent charities, package theft — but gift cards get their own line because they are both the most popular present and the easiest one to empty without anyone noticing until the card is used.

Plan to give gift cards71%of holiday shoppers, 2026
Gave or got an empty card35%“no funds available”
Fake shipping alert47%in the past year
Fake toll text44%in the past year

Two caveats on reading the 35%. It is a lifetime figure (“have ever”), not this year's rate, and it counts the giver and the recipient of the same card separately, so it is not the share of cards that are drained. AARP does not break it down by card type, by where the card was bought or by amount lost. It does say that more victims are getting some money back than in earlier years, while many still report the funds could not be restored.

“Criminals don't take a break during the holidays. They take advantage of the increased shopping.”
— Kathy Stokes, Senior Director of Fraud Prevention Programs, AARP (press release, November 11, 2026)

How a card ends up empty before anyone spends it

The usual mechanism is “card draining”: someone records the number and PIN from a card on a store rack, reseals the package, and spends the balance online once the card is activated at the till. The FTC's guidance tells buyers to check that protective stickers are intact and the PIN is not exposed, and to pick a different card and show the damaged one to staff if anything looks wrong. Its January 2026 consumer alert adds that with the number and PIN alone, a scammer can drain a card without ever holding it.

States have started to legislate. Maryland's Gift Card Scams Prevention Act, signed May 9, 2024, required concealed card data, scam warnings and staff training, effective June 1, 2025 for open-loop cards and October 1, 2025 for closed-loop cards. New Jersey's law required in-store scam notices from October 1, 2025, with enforcement of its tamper-evident packaging rules delayed to February 1, 2026. Rhode Island, New York and Delaware already had warning-sign laws. New Jersey's rules cover physical cards; purely digital codes fall outside its definition.

Quick answers for the people placing the order

Does this mean a third of our holiday cards could be empty? No. The survey measures people who have ever met an empty card, not the failure rate of any channel. It is a measure of how common the experience is — enough that a fair share of your employees will have had it happen to them, and will remember it if it happens with your gift.

Are rack cards bought at a store the main risk? The draining described by the FTC and targeted by the state laws works on physical cards displayed where anyone can handle them. Cards ordered in bulk from the issuer or an authorised distributor and delivered as codes do not sit on a public rack, which removes that particular step, though codes still need to be sent and stored carefully.

What should we keep? The FTC's advice is to keep a copy of each card and the store receipt. For a company order that means the invoice, the order or batch reference, and a record of which code went to which employee, so a dead card can be reported to the issuer quickly.

What it means for HR and procurement this season

  • Buy from the source, not from the rack. If physical cards are unavoidable, buy them from the issuer or an authorised distributor and inspect every package before handing it out.
  • Keep a code-to-person record. Order references and a per-recipient list turn “my card was empty” into a claim the issuer can trace.
  • Tell recipients to check the balance on day one. An empty card found in January is harder to recover than one reported the day it arrived.
  • Announce the delivery channel. One message saying how and when the holiday gift will arrive makes a fake “boss” request easier to spot.

For the broader market numbers behind this season's orders, see our gift card statistics for 2026 and the practical steps in buying bulk gift cards for employees; many recipients will want the Visa gift card balance check. Earlier this autumn we covered the California settlement over drained Vanilla cards and the FTC's data on gift card fraud losses. Teams that send rewards at volume can deliver digital codes through the bulk gift card API or let employees choose from the reward catalog.

Sources

  1. AARP, “How to Avoid Fraud and Scams This Holiday Season: AARP Breaks Down What to Watch Out For” (press release, November 11, 2026) — 84%, 47%, 44%, “more than 70%” and 35% figures; Kathy Stokes quote. aarp.org/press
  2. AARP Research, 2026 AARP Holiday Shopping and Scams Report (November 11, 2026), doi:10.26419/res.01110.001 — 71% planning to buy gift cards, 35% “no funds available”, recovery of losses, 89% on lawmakers, methodology (1,801 adults, June 22 – July 3, 2026, ANR Market Research Consultants). aarp.org/holidayscams2026
  3. Federal Trade Commission, “Avoiding and Reporting Gift Card Scams” (consumer advice, updated July 2023) — packaging checks, keeping a copy of the card and receipt, reporting to the issuer and ReportFraud.ftc.gov. consumer.ftc.gov
  4. Federal Trade Commission, “No, that's not your boss asking you to buy gift cards” (consumer alert, January 28, 2026) — the fake-boss “urgent favor” scam and draining with number and PIN. consumer.ftc.gov/consumer-alerts
  5. Reed Smith, “Gift card draining no more: Maryland's new law in focus” (October 31, 2024) — Maryland Gift Card Scams Prevention Act requirements and effective dates. reedsmith.com
  6. Hinshaw & Culbertson, “Several States Target Gift Card Fraud this Holiday Season by Imposing New Compliance Obligations on Retailers” (November 4, 2025) — Rhode Island, New York, Delaware, Maryland and New Jersey laws. hinshawlaw.com
  7. WRNJ Radio, “New Jersey now requires stores to post gift card scam warnings under consumer protection law” (November 15, 2025) — P.L. 2025, c.39; notice required from October 1, 2025, packaging enforcement delayed to February 1, 2026. wrnjradio.com
All sources accessed November 14, 2026.

About the author

MK
Maciej Kamieniak
Founder & CEO, Rewordin

Maciej has worked in the digital gift card and rewards industry for over 5 years. For this story he read AARP's November 11, 2026 press release and report page including its methodology, the FTC's gift card scam guidance and its January 2026 fake-boss alert, and summaries of the Maryland and New Jersey gift card laws, on November 14, 2026.